Tinkerbell 5k Lost Boys pin

[pretty_Omi]

So I forgot I already had this pin, and traded with a second one. Decided to compare in case one looked better, and noticed some discrepancies.

So the one without the card is actually brighter, has better colors, sharper printing of the faces. The backs are slightly different gold colors. I actually DON'T suspect scrapper? The pins are of the same weight, quality is too good. I honestly suspect just subtle differences in the run of the pin, but wanted to see what anyone else thought.
I also can't seem to find this one on Pinpics.

 

[LadyBarclay]

#118057, and I have seen pins have a faded look to them (swap meets with likely scrappers, trays that must be sitting out in the sun a lot). NOT saying yours is a scrapper, it would seem to me that a pin for a specific event like a 5K is less likely to be scrapped.

 

[pretty_Omi]

Thank you for the pinpics#!
Yeah, I think it might just be somehow faded, I think I'm going to keep the brighter of the two