Please help me figure out if these are fake :[

I was trying to collect the finding nemo set of each character in their plastic bags and traded for these two. now the colors are way off, they both sort of look fake, especially the one on the left with the thick silver lines and bigger hidden mickey.

then when i turn them around the left one has the two spikes near the point and a flat lined surface. the one on the right has a textured surface and no spikes ><

they both say the same thing in the boxes and mickey head so.. please help!

Unfortunately, the yellowish top is a dead giveaway for a counterfeit pin. So that one for sure is bad. Not sure on the Nemo one.

thank you

I would be worried about the one that is depicted on the right (where the backs are showing). It is missing the two side nubs and the prong is off-center.

maybe theyre both no good. sigh

The one on the left is obviously a bad pin, however the one on the right looks good and I dont believe that pin had nubs anyways.
The back of the bad pin is obvious too.

Nemo looks good.