QUESTION Trying to price pins without reference

[Icarusinflames]

I am selling my collection, but I am finding that some pins do not have listings on ebay and I am a little at a loss for their value

.

I want to sell them, but I don't even have a ballpark, I cannot find any sold listings or active listings anywhere. I know they are valuable, but just spitting out random numbers seems weird.
Does anyone know what they have gone for? Any advice on pricing pins you cant find reference of?

 

[hopemax]

Do you know about the "Product Research" tool for sellers on Ebay? It looks back 3 years not just a few months.

Go to Ebay.
Click on Sell in the Upper Right menu
You may have to accept new terms to have your account converted to include selling (no fees or anything)
Then select "Product Research" under the Research tab dropdown menu

I searched for DSSH valentine letter Tangled and got 5 results between May 2024 and March 2025. Three were $45, with one at $60 and one at $69.99

Up has 3 results, and a wide variation $35 in Feb 2024 and $89.99 in May 2024. No more recent auctions.

 

[Icarusinflames]

Do you know about the "Product Research" tool for sellers on Ebay? It looks back 3 years not just a few months.

Go to Ebay.
Click on Sell in the Upper Right menu
You may have to accept new terms to have your account converted to include selling (no fees or anything)
Then select "Product Research" under the Research tab dropdown menu

I searched for DSSH valentine letter Tangled and got 5 results between May 2024 and March 2025. Three were $45, with one at $60 and one at $69.99

Up has 3 results, and a wide variation $35 in Feb 2024 and $89.99 in May 2024. No more recent auctions.

thanks so much! I misunderstood the ability to look up past sales, this will be really useful!