Just echoing that I think they both have the potential to be legit.
When I forget to bring any lanyard traders, I will tend to just go grab a bag of whatever pins come in sets like these. I have purchased the same sets, and had the colors be dramatically different, right out of the bags before. I suspect it's just minor variances when made years apart, in different batches, from multiple factories, etc.
I would be checking the shine/polish on the pins, do some of them have any of those "stripes" where it looks like they didn't take enough time to polish the pins? That's one of the easier tells of scrappers. How's the weight between the two? Is one lighter than the other? Typically the scrappers are made with cheaper metal for the base and will not be as heavy.
Just trying to offer some other signs to see if one is scrap or not, since the colors aren't always the immediate factor.