Advice about a "Kitty"

[unibear]

Hey all,

I've been collecting the Paris pin trading night pins that have cats on them, with the idea of displaying them all together.

etc.

Recently, this one came out and I love Sully so I bought it. My question is: Should I put it in with the Cats pins?

One the one hand, I know he's not a cat. But on the other hand, Boo didn't and whenever I see a pin of Sully I always think "KITTY!"

So, what do you think about making Sully an honorary "Kitty"?

 

[tiggeriffic]

It's your collection and I think that would make it even more uniquely yours! Cute collection!

 

[OlafOlaf]

I think it's a delightful little "joke", to be honest. I'd definitely do it haha.

 

[Purplemandms]

When I first read the title of the thread, I actually thought of Sully. So I say go for it!

 

[CCofRR13]

That was the first thing I thought of was that Boo called him "Kitty" ~ I say he is an honorary member of the cat family

 

[Molly]

He's furry and sweet and answers to kitty so I say KITTY all the way!

 

[twintraders]

That's an adorable idea, add him for sure.

 

[docfish2u]

That is the great thing about personal collections, you can do whatever you want with them!!! So here kitty kitty.

 

[Jabberwocky]

I'll be the voice of dissent - he's not a cat, so to me he doesn't belong with a cat collection. That said, it's your collection, do whatever you want.

 

[froggerway]

If it has four legs and fur then yes it can be a kitty! ROFL, that's how I justify Stitch as being part of my cat collection. :naughty:

 

[Ninpin]

I "get it" and I think that anyone who has seen the movie would understand too! Cute idea, and actually makes me laugh a bit!

By the way unibear, did you get my PM? I had a question for you earlier!

 

[nsingleton]

I think it definitely belongs in the collection!

 

[Romancing_Train]

I have a running joke with my grandma...we keep the Cheshire cat dressed as a lion in my lion king frame lol

 

[Dalamara]

I'd do it :lol:

 

[caw caw rawr]

Yes! I'd totally include him

 

[CCofRR13]

If it has four legs and fur then yes it can be a kitty! ROFL, that's how I justify Stitch as being part of my cat collection. :naughty:

I consider Stitch one of my cats as well!

 

[unibear]

Thank you all so much for your feedback. The "kitty" has indeed joined my DLRP PTN collection of kitties.

The reason I bumped this is because I have a question about two "kitty" pins for my DSF/DSSH PTD collection of kitties. My question is: Should I add these two pins to my kitty collection?

I'm leaning towards 'no' with Pete because even though he's a cat, he doesn't act very "feline". He's even wearing clothes!! Kind of like I don't have a problem thinking of Pluto as a dog, but I don't tend to think of Goofy as a dog (if that makes any sense).

Clearly Rufus *is* a cat, but Penny clearly *isn't*. If it were a pin of just Rufus I'd get it in a heartbeat. So, I guess I'm wondering if I should allow Penny to invade my kitty collection as long as she brings Rufus along for the ride/drag.

What are your thoughts? Thanks in advance for the advice.

 

[tiggeriffic]

A side collection (literally or figuratively) of cats with their owners/friends would be very cool!

 

[TiggerSue]

Hi Unibear!! It was Tiggerific seeing you last night!!!

Of course Sully should be included as an honorary cat!! You include Tigger and he isn't a cat, he's a T i double-gah er!! and the only one. LOL

Hope to hear from you sometime. TTFN, Sue