What do you think has better trade value

[disneyfreak619]

I have these two pins and I cant decide which one is better someone asked for either but I cant decide which one I should keep I want to keep the one that is going to get me more in another trade I dont collect either of these characters please I need opinions

this one LE 500 trade/want 11/98

this one LE 1000 trade/want 20/188

 

[Abyssinian28]

IMO, the Jessica is the better trader. I've seen more and more of the Stitch bellhop pins going for "cheaper".

 

[erudolf]

Jessica has higher value.

 

[disneyfreak619]

alright another ? what do you think about this trade

my

pin 43099

for
their

pin 68560

im considering it because its the last alice uk pin i need tell me if it looks fair

 

[erudolf]

I don't know much about the Alice pin but I'd still pick the Jessica.

 

[Merryweather]

If you really really wanted it, maybe then.

They have similar ask/want ratios but yours is lower LE.

 

[Luis75]

Jessica, hands down. Every time I see a Jessica Pin, someone around them wants it.

 

[swim2sea]

I would offer the Stitch for the Alice. Your Jessica is a much lower LE and has more value. Trade away the Stitch for the Alice and keep Jessica for a better deal. That is only my opinion as an Alice collector.

 

[Tr8dWitMe]

I would offer the Stitch for the Alice. Your Jessica is a much lower LE and has more value. Trade away the Stitch for the Alice and keep Jessica for a better deal. That is only my opinion as an Alice collector.

If you have the option of sending 1 of the 2, keep Jessica. The Stitch is LE 1000. Even if its an ok trade ratio, remember that 500 can still be on the trade block. Usually everyone bought 2 each. One to keep and one to trade. So if eventually someone brings out one to trade, the wants will go down but still having one left will keep the trade number the same.

Only the LE 500 will show a reduction of trade/want ratio. And being a Jessica means higher value and trade worth. Of any popular character, always keep the lower LE that has the better ratio.

 

[snazzybowtie]

Definitely keep the Jessica. I can never seem to keep her in my book. The moment I get a Jessica I trade it becaue someone always wants it. With stitch I usually have him for awhile and some I still have.

 

[disneyfreak619]

but now the person says they only want the jessica do you think its worth it . its hard for me to give up i like the pin but i dont collect jessica but i dont want to just give it away either . do you think its at least a some what close trade the jessica for the alice

 

[erudolf]

Personally, I'd pass or tell them they need to add more. I did a quick look last night and saw the Alice pin on eBay for $39 BIN. I'll look again, but I'm guessing you could get it for less than that.

 

[HeatherFeather]

In the words of the great Kenny Rogers...

You got to know when to hold 'em, know when to fold 'em
Know when to walk away and know when to run

Might be time to run.

 

[lunarbasket]

I think I paid $20ish for my Alice uk pin, I wouldn't trade Jessica for it